New events center raises questions about Cummins Hill safety

Westfall supervisors approve project unanimously: Developers say the center will be small scale and devoted to family parties

Make text smaller Make text larger


  • Tim Day, president of Crawford Hill Community, addresses the Westfall supervisors (Photo by Marilyn Rosenthal)

  • The board of supevisors (Photo by Marilyn Rosenthal)

  • Residents came out to learn more about the events center proposed for Cummins Hill Road (Photo by Marilyn Rosenthal)

By Marilyn Rosenthal

— An events center coming to Cummins Hill has neighbors worried, especially about increased traffic on local roads.

A crowd turned out for a two-hour Westfall town meeting on the Peckham Properties Associates, LLC-Event Center, which applied for a conditional-use permit to build an events center at 170 Cummins Hill Road. After a two-hour discussion, the supervisors unanimously agreed the project has met all the conditions required to move forward.

'Not totally opposed'Anticipating an out-of-control audience flare-up, Robert Bernathy, the township's attorney, forcefully laid down rules of order at the start of the long meeting: no shouting out, no talking among themselves, no interrupting anyone who had the floor.

One of the most vocal audience members was Tim Day, president of the Crawford Hill Community, located less than a mile uphill from the proposed center.

"We are not totally opposed, but have some concerns," Day said.

Road safety was their primary concern, he said. The proposed driveway is on a blind turn, he said, and the road may be damaged in constructing the center. He suggested that the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (PennDOT) do a traffic study that goes beyond the posted 25-mile-per-hour speed limit to measure the speeds cars actually do, while also looking at road grades and lines of sight up and down the hill.

Peckham Properties was represented by attorney Douglas Jacobs, who responded forcefully.

"Should my client be restricted because some people drive fast?" he asked.

Day asked if Peckham Properties was going to build a residential community on the site.

Mr. Day lived in a community, said Jacobs, so why would he be against others building a community?

Supervisor Jerry Dotey asked Day how long he has lived in the Crawford Hill Community. Day answered, "One year," which led some to snicker.

A rare opportunityThe meeting was not about building a community, however.

Bernathy said the Westfall Planning Commission had recommended that the supervisors approve the center, as long as 12 conditions were met. The purpose of the meeting, he said, was not only to allow public discussion but for the supervisors to decide whether the applicant has met the conditions.

"We have a lot of folks here who just don't want (the center), but the decision by the supervisors will not be based on emotional reasons," he said.

Linnea Geno, the daughter of Geoffrey Peckham, lives on the 163-acre property with her husband and their two-year-old. She's lived there for most of her 25 years, she said.

The property borders a 30-acre parcel that includes an 1840s house and barn. The events center will be small scale, and mainly used for weekend events like weddings and family reunions. They would use the footprints of existing buildings, which would be renovated: the barn would be used for gatherings, while the farmhouse would accommodate guests of these gatherings who wanted to stay overnight.

Geno said she and her husband love their home and are attached to the land. Developing the center will allow them to make a living in a beautiful spot, where there aren't many opportunities for young people, she said. In the future, she said, the property might be used for one-day business or yoga retreats that would not require overnight stays.

Geoffrey Peckham also stressed that he was a long-time resident of 25 years, a conservationist, and a member of Trout Unlimited. He said his values go hand in hand with the way he lived his life.

Mary Ann Halkias, who lives diagonally across from the proposed site, said water was eroding her property and suggested the applicant choose a different spot for the driveway.

Bernathy noted that Westfall has no jurisdiction over Cummins Hill Road, which is a state road, and that PennDOT would have to deal with those issues.

Next up: MalibuThe board of supervisors then scheduled another conditional use hearing — this one for Malibu Land Holdings, LLC, on its proposed Foster Hill Road Wellness Center, at 5 p.m. on Tuesday, Sept. 5, at the township building.

And it's expected there will be a huge crowd at that hearing too.

About the center

Linnea Geno stated her intentions regarding the proposed events center:
It will be open from April 1-Oct. 30 only
Geno will meet with potential guests before they booked the center
Food and drinks will be brought in and not prepared on the premises
Outside noise will stop at 11 p.m. and inside noise at midnight
Guests will be limited to 175 guests
A new driveway will give access to the property

Westfall's complicated geography

Many people who do not live in Westfall Township are surprised to learn that both Cummins Hill Road and parts of Foster Hill Road are actually in Westfall and not Milford.
Westfall Township zigs and zags, starting at the Tractor Supply Company (which lists its address as Routes 6 and 209, Milford) and extending to the Wells Fargo Bank in Matamoras. It starts up again on Delaware Drive, past Avenue C, through Mill Rift, and then onto Bluestone Boulevard in Mill Rift, which turns into Cummins Hill Road. It comes back down Route 6, behind Polar Bear Ice Cream in Matamoras, then to Foster Hill Road (Malibu Ranch lists its address as 351 Foster Hill Rd., Milford), and then on to Pond Eddy, N.Y.
So Westfall Township actually encompasses three different postal addresses; Milford, Matamoras, and Mill Rift.

Make text smaller Make text larger


Pool Rules


Medicaid recipients to get work requirements
Rewriting the rules on health care for the poor, the Trump administration said Jan. 12 it will allow states to require “able-bodied"...

Read more »

Pike Chamber to hold annual installation dinner
— The Pike County Chamber of Commerce will hold its annual installation dinner and general membership meeting at 5:30 p.m. on...
Read more »

Pennsylvania issues disaster declaration over opioid crisis
Pennsylvania's governor declared the state's opioid addiction epidemic a public health emergency on Jan. 10 and ordered a command center set up to treat the...

Read more »

Agreement on need, but not location, for methadone/suboxone clinic
By Anya Tikka
— A methadone/suboxone walk-in clinic is in the plans for Port Jervis that will serve addicts bused in from...

Read more »


* indicates required
Community Newspapers


Weather in Milford, PA